“A Tactile Obedience”
A Review of
Spiritual Formation Through
THE BOOK OF COMMON PRAYER.
by David DeSilva.
By Mark Eckel.
From time to time during my professorial days at Moody Bible Institute, I would attend an Episcopalian church close by my house. I did this because I felt like such a sinner taking communion there. In that denomination, partaking of the bread and wine is a very kinesthetic experience (e.g. physical movement is required). One had to stand and walk down the middle aisle in front of everyone. Kneeling at the altar, the sacraments were given to you by another without your help. Returning to my seat, the thought repetitiously came to my mind, “I am a sinner saved by grace. I am a sinner saved by grace. I am a sinner…” Often I would stop after the first four words. Physical activity dictated that I be physically, visibly reminded of my status before God. Most Evangelicals have an autonomous, individualistic approach to communion: we take the elements ourselves as they are passed. I need the bodily movement to remind me that I do nothing of myself without His aid.
And so DeSilva says, “We might like to think of ourselves as our own masters, which is prized among our cultural ideals . . . we seek to preserve the illusion of running our own show” (53). What is so profound about Sacramental Life is just that kind of direct application. DeSilva hits me where I live with words from The Book of Common Prayer impacting every movement of life.
Relevance to daily living is consistently tactile, including touch (37), taste (82), and smell (47). Christians have been making themselves aware of their devotion to God through liturgies found in The Book of Common Prayer for years. The four major sections of Sacramental Life force the reader back to contemplate and practice these prayers. Baptism, Eucharist, Marriage and Burial relate to aspects of life with which believers consistently interact. Each small chapter (there are forty-five) could function itself as a daily guide for individuals or groups. At the conclusion of every few pages a section entitled “putting it into practice” gives the reader livable guidelines, implementing physically what she has just read verbally.
The chapters consistently offer new threads of connection to the Christian life. During communion, for instance, the necessity of remembering (82), confronting conflicts (88), and transparency (97-98) are explained. DeSilva summarizes, “We cannot be right with God when we are at odds with one another” (110). Our confession of sin (100-108) with the emphasis on self-examination impacts our humble patience with others. Genuine sorrow is indicative of genuine intention.
Life application is constant. “Giving gifts” (156) indicates the depth of our relation to God making adoration “a lifestyle” (144). Sacramental Life minces no words in skewering consumerism (113) or in referencing the problems associated with spontaneous prayers versus those already written (124-134). Marriage counselors would do well to visit pages 195-224 often as they guide young couples toward their vows. Vignettes and anecdotes from years of pastoral counseling breathe life into each biblical injunction. I was pleasantly surprised to read DeSilva’s reference to keeping a human skull visible through portrait, reminding us all that life does come to an end, teaching us to number our days (239). A similar picture in my office is a visible prompt to live each day for Christ, knowing life is a vapor.
DeSilva makes many astute theological comments. Whether biblical words are being defined (“temptation” as “trial” in The Lord’s Prayer, 140), an exposition of a passage is elucidated (135-141), denominational terms are described (“collect” as the gathered petitions from assembled members, 118), or the intersection of New Testament backgrounds to explain the problem of idolatry (152) is detailed, new insights can be gained in each chapter. DeSilva’s penchant for architecture (146, 151) reflects my own as I spent half my time walking to the train in downtown Chicago looking up at the beautiful buildings! A few doctrinal differences will raise eyebrows with some: prayers for the dead (130-133) or apocryphal books as guides (144). However, what is most impressive are the constant, full references to Scripture from where Sacramental Life gains its foundation.
Taking weekly communion where a church body practices the physical, visible process of remembering Jesus’ death, burial, and resurrection is surely helpful to believers. DeSilva’s fine book should be available to all who want to embody their beliefs. Penitence to praise enlivens every page. Yet beyond the obvious connections to life, it is important for Christians to renew both their examination of and excitement for their belief. DeSilva might be pleased to know I ordered my first Book of Common Prayer. Even at fifty, it is not too late to begin a more ordered Sacramental Life.
Mark Eckel is director of
C. Christopher Smith is the founding editor of The Englewood Review of Books. He is also author of a number of books, including most recently How the Body of Christ Talks: Recovering the Practice of Conversation in the Church (Brazos Press, 2019). Connect with him online at: C-Christopher-Smith.com