We are reading:
Abraham Joshua Heschel
<<<<< PART ONE
(If you are running behind, you are still welcome
to contribute the previous conversation)
Reading: Chapters I and II (pages 12-33)
Facilitator: Katy Drage Lines
Katy compiled the following discussion questions, and will be facilitating our conversation in the comments below.
These questions are intended to get conversation rolling. Please feel free to ask your own questions, or make your own observations, about this week’s reading in the comment section below.
- I have long been fascinated by time. I’m drawn to good science/fiction movies like Interstellar that explore the connection between space and time. Jesus’ interaction with Moses and Elijah in the Transfiguration is another compelling story—how the Creator of time stood both within and outside of time. Finally, I think of the old hymn, “Of the Father’s Love Begotten”—ere the worlds began to be/ He is Alpha and Omega/ He the Source, the ending he/ of the things that are, that have been, and that future years shall be. Heschel, too, traverses time and the liminal holiness of a specific time, the Sabbath. What words, metaphors, imagery does Heschel play with that draw you into Sabbath time? Why? What is the liminal nature of Sabbath? Think about the various calendars we use; how do/can we order time to recognize its holiness? How can followers of Jesus practice recognizing holiness in time, as part of God’s good creation?
- If you have the edition of Heschel’s book that includes Ilya Schor’s wood engravings, give a bit of your time to exploring that artwork, and perhaps the story of the artist himself. What details do you observe in particular pieces? How do you see them connecting with Heschel’s themes?
- Much of what Heschel depicts is as an individual’s posture towards the Sabbath. How do we, as members of a particular community of the Body of Christ, express or respond to this? How do we respond as a community together to the holiness of time?
- I imagine we’ve all seen “keeping the Sabbath” used both within Jewish and Christian circles as a strict form of legalism. Yet here, Heschel creates imagery that shapes a day that’s longed for, not legalistic, the “climax of living” (p. 14). How do we build/enter/maintain a ritual like Sabbath-keeping that is not legalistic but liberating? And how can we convey that to future generations?
- Heschel writes, “to observe [the seventh day] is to celebrate the creation of the world and to create the seventh day all over again, the majesty of holiness in time” (pp. 19-20). How do we participate in the Creator’s (capital C) creation of time as fellow creators (small c), through Sabbath participation?
- As Heschel described the menuha experienced on the Sabbath (pp. 22-23), I found myself comparing it to the shalom of God that is the Kingdom of God (yet Heschel never connects it to shalom—I wonder why). Heschel calls it “the essence of good life;” and “happiness and stillness,… peace and harmony;” and “a synonym for the life in the world to come, for eternal life.” How do you find yourself connecting to menuha, that which is more than “withdrawal from labor, freedom from toil”? Do you find it connecting to your practices this Lenten season?
- Heschel asks, “Is there any institution that holds out greater hope for man’s [sic] progress than the Sabbath? The solution of mankind’s most vexing problem will not be found in renouncing technical civilization, but in attaining some degree of independence from it” (p. 28). How would you answer his question? He originally wrote this in 1951; what has changed (or hasn’t changed) since then that might lead us to answer this differently than Heschel might have? Do you agree with him? Why or why not?
Logistics of our Conversation:
Our conversation will unfold in the comment section below. Feel free to answer any of the above questions or to ask your own questions or add your observations about the reading. If you are adding a new question / observation, please do so as a new comment, not as a reply to another comment. If you are responding to someone else’s comment, please use “REPLY” instead of responding in a new top-level comment.
If you have not left a comment on the ERB website before, your first comment will have to be moderated, and may take up to 24 hours to appear. But once you have an approved comment, you will generally be able to post without moderation.
Feel free to disagree with other participants, but do so with gentleness and respect. Comments that do not follow this rule of thumb may be deleted.
Check in often to see how the conversation is going. (Unfortunately, we do not have the technological capacity to email you when new comments are added)
About our facilitator:
Katy Drage Lines is a pastor at Englewood Christian Church in Indianapolis. Prior to settling in Indy’s Near Eastside two years ago, she served churches and universities in such diverse places as Southern California, Kentucky, Kenya, and Tennessee, though she’s originally from Colorado. She’s the board chair for Christian HolyLand Foundation, which partners with Arab believers in Galilee, and she regularly visits and encourages Christians around the world through CMF International, where her husband is Executive Director. She is delighted to celebrate the recent completion of her DMin through Portland Seminary, with her dissertation on Re-Imagining Communion as a Place of Belonging and Hospitality. She’s thrilled to take a Sabbath rest from writing for school, but couldn’t pass up the opportunity to guide this week’s discussion.
C. Christopher Smith is the founding editor of The Englewood Review of Books. He is also author of a number of books, including most recently How the Body of Christ Talks: Recovering the Practice of Conversation in the Church (Brazos Press, 2019). Connect with him online at: C-Christopher-Smith.com
Reading for the Common Good
From ERB Editor Christopher Smith
"This book will inspire, motivate and challenge anyone who cares a whit about the written word, the world of ideas, the shape of our communities and the life of the church."
-Karen Swallow Prior
Enter your email below to sign up for our weekly newsletter & download your FREE copy of this ebook!