Archives For King Arthur

 

Myth-ing Persons

 
A review of 

The Inklings and King Arthur:
J.R.R. Tolkien, Charles Williams, C.S. Lewis and Owen Barfield on the Matter of Britain
 

Sørina Higgins, Ed.

Paperback: Apocryphile, 2018
Buy Now:  [ Amazon ]  [ Kindle ]

 
Reviewed by Sam Edgin
 

I remember, as a child, trying to find my definitive King Arthur book. Stories of fell swords and dangerous magic had seized me like they do many other children. I was fascinated by the possibilities of mysterious power carried within Christian relics, fresh with the adventures of Indiana Jones were running amok in my imagination. Mostly, though, I was harboring a strange obsession with the tale of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. It resonated within me, and I wanted more about Gawain and his bargains, steeped in chivalry and loyalty and hazy magic. I’m not sure I was ever sated – the efforts to find an Arthuriana found me Roger Lancelyn Green, whose Arthur and Gawain seemed lacking, but whose Robin Hood was so similar to the Robin Hood I saw in movies. Distracted, I seldom returned to Gawain and the castle in the forest.

Continue Reading…

 

A World of Marvels and Magic
 
A Feature Review of

The Fall of Arthur: An Epic Poem
J.R.R. Tolkien
edited by Christopher Tolkien

Hardcover, HM Harcourt, 2013
Buy now:  [ Amazon ]   [ Kindle ]

 
Reviewed by Holly Ordway

 

As J.R.R. Tolkien’s friend C.S. Lewis put it, before one judges the merits of anything – from a corkscrew to a cathedral – it is necessary to know what it is, and thus what for what use it is intended. Conversely, once one knows what something is for, one can decide whether it is the thing one is looking for. If after Sunday Mass one wants to have a pint of beer and a nice lunch, it’s no good staying in the cathedral; one must go to the pub down the road.
 
This point is relevant for a review of Tolkien’s The Fall of Arthur because, perhaps more than other recent releases, it may not be immediately clear what it is.

Continue Reading…

 

A Brief Review of
THE HAWK AND THE WOLF.
Mark Adderley.

Hardback: WestBank Publishing, 2008.
Buy now: [ Amazon ]

Reviewed by Jonathan Schindler.

    The Hawk and the Wolf is the first in Mark Adderley’s The Matter of Britain series and follows young Emrys (Merlin) as he wanders about Britain searching for the lost sword Excalibur, pining for his forbidden love, Boudicea, and learning how to use his gift of “the Sight.”

    The book, as Adderley describes in his useful introduction, does not seek to recover the “historical Merlin,” as the horrid King Arthur (2004) film did for its namesake, nor does he attempt a rehash of Merlin the mythic character. Adderley’s tale and world is his own. Merlin’s Britain in The Hawk and the Wolf is situated somewhere between the mystical world of legend and the cold world of modern historical imaginings. (Adderley says his “aim is to tell the kind of story that would have been told in the Middle Ages,” xi.) He also chooses a unique setting for the story—the first century AD—which allows him to weave in the story of Boudicea, the doomed warrior princess on a mission to save her homeland. Adderley has certainly done his homework (and, for the reader’s benefit, he suggests some further reading), which infuses the story with rich detail.

    The story of Merlin is, in the popular consciousness, closely tied to Arthurian legend. For this reason, I find Adderley’s choice to place The Hawk and the Wolf in the first century fascinating. Throughout the book references are made to a man who endured “a triple death” (scourging, hanging, and being pierced by a spear; 158) or to warriors who “all wore the same symbol, like a tree but stylized, formalized, and upon it hung a man” (175). I am uncertain where Adderley’s future volumes will go—whether they will transport Arthur back to this historical setting or leave him out completely—but Adderley’s allusions lead to the inescapable comparison of two Messianic figures and make for interesting speculation while reading.

    Adderley chooses a setting when there is certainly a lot that happens, which keeps the story moving at a suitable pace. What didn’t work so well for me was his method of telling it (which hinges on Merlin’s age). The narration is in third-person and follows Merlin wherever he goes. Merlin is cast as an angsty teenager, and his emotions continually draw him this way and that. His abilities allow him to feel what others are feeling, but because his wanderings (and his age) necessitate it, his stay is brief wherever he goes. This makes it difficult for the reader to empathize in the same way. Merlin may have an attachment to characters (as even a brief encounter with other humans is liable to have an impact), but in the written word, attachments are not so easily formed. In this way, I felt left outside the drama at certain points in the story. I’m assuming the reader’s emotional distance from Merlin will lessen in future books as Merlin grows older and more stable.

    Despite this quibble, Adderley has written an entertaining and engaging story, one that is likely to get more interesting and intense as it continues over the forthcoming books. He has a clear enthusiasm for his subject (which is not always the case, but is always refreshing), making The Hawk and the Wolf ripe reading material for Merlin enthusiasts and lovers of fantasy.